Sign In

We need effective national standards for service animals

April 22, 2020

The problem of fraudulent service animals will continue despite the U.S. Department of Transportation’s recent attempts to remedy the issue. The time for public comment on proposed amendments to the Air Carrier Access Act service animal rule has ended with no promise that the amendments will remedy the situation.

The proposed amendment would do a number of extremely helpful things. To start, it would align the ACAA’s definition of a service animal with that of the Department of Justice’s Americans with Disabilities Act. Airlines would no longer treat emotional support animals as service animals, but as pets (which is still a highly contentious issue). And airlines would limit service animals to dogs, instead of the previous range of odd animals.

These are overdue changes to the law. However, the ACAA is also proposing to require passengers to complete a form attesting to their service dogs’ behavior, training, waste relief ability and vaccination record. Although these proposed changes appear to be helpful, they will not do enough to change a broken system. And they may simply add a burden for individuals with disabilities who want to fly.

The problem with the current ADA regulations and the proposed DOT’s regulations is that there is no national system regulating vets and verifies and licenses service dogs. This is equivalent to Americans printing out their own handicap parking permits without going through the DMV.

The ADA allows people to train their own service dogs, and there are no national standards or regulations defining requirements for service dog training or behavior. Service dogs are not even required to pass a simple “canine good citizen” or “public access test” to prove they can behave safely in public. This puts the public, ill-trained service animals and well-trained service animals at risk.

But standards exist for service dogs. For example, Assistance Dog Internationals has stringent requirements their service dogs must pass. The United States could adopt the requirements.

Many people are not aware that well-trained, legitimate service dogs often require extensive training (learning as many as 40 commands), medical assessments and behavioral assessments. They may cost upward of $40,000-$60,000.

The U.S. should create recognizable IDs for service dogs. Rather than having the Department of Transportation decree dogs are the only valid service animals, it should work with the ADA to establish a national licensing system.

Service animal fraud and abuse is rampant, and harms individuals with disabilities (and their trained service animals) — those who need these animals the most. Airlines reported 2,433 complaints in 2016 related to service animals, 2,473 complaints in 2017 and 3,065 in 2018. There are numerous fraudulent service dog programs, which extort individuals with disabilities by providing fake service dogs. Unethical clinicians are falsifying disability documents through online services. Fake service animals continue to harm the reputation of legitimate service animals.

As a clinical psychologist who works with individuals with mental health issues, many of whom ask for service dogs or have them, I believe strongly that legitimate service dogs are necessary. But we need to do better. The U.S. needs a centralized process that approves service dogs and provides credentials. Sadly, the Department of Transportation’s proposed amendments won’t get us there.

Register Your Dog

  • Most Recent News

    Izzy The Therapy Dog

    There is something different strolling the halls of schools in Moody this year and she’s soft, gentle and loves kids. Her name is Izzy and she is a two-year-old Goldendoodle, turned therapy dog. Her owner, Sgt. Ron Richardson, with the Moody Police Department, saw a video of a therapy dog being used in Cullman County […]

    Read more

    Animal Advocate

    Penny, a spaniel mix who works as a canine advocate for domestic violence victims through Crisis Center North, is nearing retirement. She was adopted from Action for Animals in Derry Township and attends court dates with victims to provide emotional support. But before she retires, she has one more job. She needs to train an […]

    Read more

    Dog Chow Campaign

    In honor of National Service Dog Awareness Month, Purina Dog Chow is launching its third annual “Service Dog Salute” campaign. A service dog can be life-changing in helping veterans with PTSD and other post-combat challenges. Unfortunately, due to the cost and time it takes to train a service dog, less than 1% of veterans in […]

    Read more

    Therapy Dog In School

    A Derry primary school this week welcomed a new member of staff – its very own therapy dog. Joy will be used to provide comfort and reassurance to pupils at St Oliver Plunkett Primary School after studies have shown that therapy dogs have a positive impact on children’s mood and behaviour. St Oliver Plunkett is […]

    Read more

    Polices Therapy Dog

    The Great Barrington police department is holding a swearing in ceremony Friday for its new therapy dog, Officer Beko. Beko is a 16-week old black lab and works with Officer Kris Balestro. Beko’s training, certification and care are funded by donations from the local community. Officer Beko is the first therapy dog to join a […]

    Read more

    BarkBox Launching Essentials

    If your dog loves to monitor your work when you’re cooking, generally gets underfoot the entire time and sees “taste tester” as their official title, these new dog toys may be essential in your kitchen. Starting Oct. 1, Bed, Bath & Beyond is introducing a new line, specifically tailored to your dog’s kitchen needs. In […]

    Read more